E-Book Overview
This study pioneers the use of insights from cognitive sciences, such as evolutionary biology, neuroscience, and developmental psychology, as heuristic tools for interpreting ancient texts. The approach could be described as 'psycho-biological'. The focus is on emotions in the various Pentateuchal legal collections. Kazen discusses the role of disgust, empathy, fear, and a sense of justice, for particular moral and ritual issues: purity and holiness; humanitarian concern for vulnerable categories; ethnocentrism and xenophobia; divine punishment and demonic threat; revenge, compensation, and ransom (kofer), together with removal (kipper) rites. The book consists of two main parts, framed by an introductory chapter and a concluding discussion. In the first part, Kazen explores cognitive foundations, including biological and neuroscientific underpinnings for basic affects, and the role of culture in shaping both conventional morality and ritual behaviour. Four particular emotions are then outlined. In the second part, these insights from cognitive science are applied in analyses of particular texts. After an overview of the Pentateuchal legal collections, each of the four emotions is dealt with in a separate chapter. Kazen constantly relates a cognitive science approach to more traditional source and redaction-critical analysis, regarding them as complementary. As a result, the Pentateuchal legal collections are seen as emotional texts, expressing strong affects-which influences our understanding of the character of Israelite 'law'. Kazen suggests that interaction and conflict between various emotions can explain discrepancies and tensions between humanitarian concerns and ethnocentrism, and between empathy and justice. He also demonstrates that viewing emotions as common denominators contains a potential for solving some difficult and long-standing conundrums. He argues that a focus on the human embodied experience rather than on theological convictions and theoretical ideas may avoid some interpretative dead ends and open up new avenues for understanding ancient texts.
E-Book Content
Emotions in Biblical Law
Hebrew Bible Monographs, 36 Series Editors David J.A. Clines, J. Cheryl Exum, Keith W. Whitelam Editorial Board A. Graeme Auld, Marc Brettler, Francis Landy, Stuart D.E. Weeks
Emotions in Biblical Law A Cognitive Science Approach
Thomas Kazen
Sheffield Phoenix Press 2011
Copyright © 2011 Sheffield Phoenix Press Published by Sheffield Phoenix Press Department of Biblical Studies, University of Sheffield, 45 Victoria Street, Sheffield S3 7QB UK www.sheffieldphoenix.com
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or any information storage or retrieval system, without the publishers’ permission in writing.
A CIP catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Typeset by ISB Typesetting Printed on acid-free paper by Lightning Source UK Ltd, Milton Keynes
ISBN 978-1-907534-29-4 (hardback) ISSN 1747-9614
(Studia Theologica Holmiensia, 19: ISSN 1401-1557)
Contents Preface Abbreviations
ix xii Introduction
Chapter 1 The Role of the Body in Religion
3
Part I Cognitive Foundations Chapter 2 Evolution, Emotion and Morality: A Biological Perspective Biblical Studies and Cognitive Sciences Rationality and Emotion Morality and Emotion Morality and Evolution
9 9 10 12 16
Chapter 3 Morality, Convention and Ritual: The Role of Culture Culture and Morality Culture and Convention Ritual and Morality Moral and Ritual Impurity Metaphorical Language Comparative Evidence
20 20 21 23 24 26 28
Chapter 4 Four ‘Moral’ Emotions: Disgust, Empath